| Exceptional | Good | Acceptable |
| -Connects the summer reading to forum speakers or first-year courses -Shows actions taken as a result of the learning experience -Relates personal experiences with the summer reading |
-Discusses forum speakers or first year courses, but doesn't connect them to the summer reading -Shows specific learning -Discusses personal experiences |
-Discusses the summer reading -Shows that the book has been read -Implies personal experience with the summer reading |